Customer Testimonials
Jared and Kenny in the service department are the BEST! Outstanding communication & exceptional customer service. They both go above and beyond. Highly recommend them both to work with!
Great store! Great staff!
Buying my first brand-new car was a huge milestone. I walked into this dealership with my guard all the way up after a very disappointing experience elsewhere. My previous dealership left me feeling like honesty and integrity had taken a back seat, so I wasn't expecting much.
Then I met Nic.
From the very beginning, Nic was professional, respectful, honest, and genuinely willing to work toward a solution that was fair for both of us. I asked a lot of questions, advocated for myself, and probably tested his patience more than once. If he was ever frustrated, he never ... Read More 
Facebook - Jul 2, 2026
Best dealership experience I’ve ever had, period. I called about a truck and spoke to Kelsie, told her which one I wanted and for and the structure I looking to achieve. She handled most of the communication then Tyler worked with me to close the deal. He promised “no hassle” and delivered big time! We took care of most of the transaction via text and by the time I actually got to the dealership the truck was prepped and paperwork was ready. I was in and out in just about 30 minutes. Tyler and I even joked that it may ... Read More 
Facebook - Dec 21, 2025
Have you ever met a car dealership team that seemed like family? Well, this team is here at McDaniel Toyota in Marion. From Tyler Kline in sales to John Halko the manager to the entire sales and finance team. The purchase was seamless, simple and straightforward. I will never compare buying a new car to having a root canal again. Thank you all for a fun-filled time and restoring my faith in car dealership personnel. Happy holidays to you all. Deborah Chandler
My wife and I bought a brand new 2025 Sienna. We drove 2 hours to be able to get a new one in our price range that was available on a lot. The price couldn't be beat at invoice not MSRP. Kelsie started our process, Dustin Davis finished. It was one of the smoothest transactions we have ever done. Quick and easy then back on the road. A++++++
After several weeks of comparison shopping vehicles online, McDaniel Toyota came through! They provided a great deal on a 2022 Toyota Rav4 and offered a very fair price for my trade-in. Tyler Easterday was responsive, informative, courteous, and professional in helping me find and purchase a vehicle I was interested in. Most importantly, he was open and honest in answering the questions I had. Despite living about an hour away from the dealership, I won't hesitate to make Tyler E. at McDaniel Toyota my first contact the next time I am in the market for a vehicle. Five out of ... Read More 
DealerRater - Jun 5, 2025
I had an outstanding experience purchasing my Toyota Camry, and I can’t thank Colton enough for making it so seamless! From the moment I walked into the dealership, Colton was friendly, knowledgeable, and genuinely invested in helping me find the perfect car. He took the time to understand my needs, walked me through the Camry’s impressive features—like its smooth ride, great fuel efficiency, and top-notch safety ratings—and answered all my questions with patience and expertise. Colton’s no-pressure approach made me feel confident in my decision, and he went above and beyond to secure a fantastic ... Read More 
Google - May 30, 2025
Everyone was very friendly and helpful!
Always great to work with the team at McDaniel. Yesterday, I contacted Bryson and man did he work his magic. Got us in a vehicle that worked for our growing family at the price that worked best for us! He had us work with Kyle and Chris to finish up. They are knowledgeable and have great customer service! Rob Knight runs a great store! Thanks for everything!
Friendly, kind and helpful employees.
Shout out to Shawn Taylor and every single person we interacted with at McDaniel Toyota—from the cheerful gentleman who greeted us at the door, to the person in the finance office (I didn’t catch her name, sorry!), and especially to Shawn, who was incredibly helpful, kind, and never pushy. From my first inquiry, Shawn was responsive, regularly checked in, gave me updates on incoming inventory, and patiently answered all of my many questions - without pressure.
This was my first time buying a car, and I’ll admit I was nervous. I expected the stereotypical car dealership experience—... Read More 
Google - May 18, 2025
Hands down the easiest buying experience I have ever done. My dad purchased from there about 3 years ago and I started looking online for a Tundra and this one checked all the boxes. And it happened to be at McDaniel. We drove an hour and half to come see the new Tundra and upon returning from the test drive. We were done with paperwork in no time. I wish they were closer for future service needs, but when I am ready for another Toyota they will be my go too.
Highly recommend! Just purchased a 2025 Tundra and the experience was super easy compared to other dealerships!
McDonald GM superstore has got to be "hands down" the best experience when buying a vehicle that I have ever experienced. First of all I called to make sure the particular car I was interested was on the lot before making the drive. My sales consultant Dean Niederkohr walked the lot looking for the car and called me back to let me know that the car was on the lot. We were then met by Mr. Niederkohr who was very warm, friendly and had a calm demeanor. After the test drive, we decided to buy the car, but ... Read More 
Google - May 7, 2025
Dealt with Colton Dickerson. Great to work with. Knowledgeable and helpful. An asset to the company.
Bought a 2025 Camry with the help of Joe Peters and I couldn’t have been more pleased throughout the entire process!
I was looking for a prius. I already had an offer from another dealership. I just called to check if they can beat it. I spoke to a salesperson named Joe peters. The model which they had was a trim above the offer I had. But joe was really transparent and honest about the pricing . Also considering the value for each trim he actually offered a good deal. Joe was patient to hear my requirements. Talk me through the deal. Unfortunately I went with the first offer just because my girlfriend liked the color. Even when I was going ahead ... Read More 
Google - May 3, 2025
I highly recommend Shawn Taylor. He made the purchase of my new vehicle a great experience. He is friendly, knowledgeable, and easy to work with. By far the easiest, smoothest transaction I have had buying from a dealership. I also got a new vehicle st a very good price! Highly recommend him
Simple, transparent, smooth transaction. I highly recommend Shaun if you’re looking to buy- he is knowledgeable and thorough. I did not spend all day haggling and chasing a fair price, which was far better than previous experiences with other dealerships.
Everyone at the dealership was absolutely awesome! Dean, our salesman, was outstanding during and after the sale! Great place to shop!
Great experience
Dan Clouse was the best salesman!
Just picked up my cool red Honda Accord that I purchased from McDaniel in Marion. Joe was our sales person who was excellent. He listened to our requests and made it happen while being very polite and professional. Joe and some other staff members even stayed after so I could come some quite a distance to pick up my new baby shortly after they closed. I hope they have what I need for my next ride as they were all a pleasure to deal with. Thank you-
Wouldn’t recommend Joe Peters as a salesman. Very arrogant person to deal with. Decided to go with another vehicle make that offered a better deal. And his response was “LOL….” Not every professional. Will definitely not go back in the future
I have bought many vehicles over the years and dealerships are not all a like. Shawn Taylor and the McDaniel staff truly are solid and honest people. Shawn was extremely easy to work with, it was a no b.s experience. I wish all sales personnel’s and teams worked as well as they did.
My wife and I were looking for the perfect “new “ used vehicle for our budget. Tyler Easterday introduced himself, and, in a nutshell, he went the distance to make sure that is exactly what we were presented with! He was very easy to work with, worked tirelessly to make it happen, was very knowledgeable, and transparent throughout the process. Tyler made the whole experience actually enjoyable! Thanks again for helping us get that perfect for us Toyota! Thank you McDaniel Toyota folks for a positive experience. Bryan and Donyell Wenig
Shawn Taylor is the go to guy when it comes to buying a vehicle!
Shawn Taylor did a good job appreciate it a lot Nick
A few weeks ago, I purchased a gently used Toyota Rav 4 Hybrid for my daughter who will be graduating from college this spring. Shawn Taylor was great to work with. I asked for the racing stripes to be removed from the sides of the vehicle and to pick it up on a Sunday, when the dealership is closed. Shawn graciously accommodated both requests and paid close attention to other customer needs during the purchasing process. We are very happy with the vehicle and our experience at McDaniel Toyota. Thanks, Shawn!
I am delighted to recommend McDaniel Toyota! Our experience was exceptional when I traded in my Toyota lease. Previously, I relied on Great Lakes in Findlay, OH, but McDaniel has truly set a new standard.
Choosing to finance this time, McDaniel was incredibly accommodating. Our salesman, Alan, was outstanding—informative, knowledgeable, and genuinely personable. He perfectly embodied the professionalism expected from a salesman, never being pushy, and ensuring he understood all our preferences for the new car. The entire staff was exceptional, and we even had the pleasure of meeting the sales manager, which is a rare occurrence. Overall, it ... Read More 
Google - Mar 19, 2025
GMC was fast and easy on fixing my recall! Thanks so much! My vehicle is driving way better and has more power! I’m loving it! Louann Perry
Quick, no hassle experience. Rob was very helpful and had everything ready for me when I arrived.
I got a vehicle and I am in love! Shawn was amazing and definitely made the process very smooth!
Once again you guys done a great job and I like to give appreciation to jarred for taking care of me. Thank you.
Purchased a new GMC truck on 3/10, and was the dealership experience I've had. Started online and got immediate response. They were extremely fair with my trade in truck. Pretty much everything was done from home except test drive and pickup. Drove over an hour to the dealership. Everyone was extremely helpful. Sales associate Nic done an awesome job for me. Thanks everyone at McDaniels GM.
Great job!! No pressure, courteous and professional sales group! Jody very helpfull explaining features of truck and helped me setting up My Chevrolet app. Dan (finance) did a great job setting me up with a good payment plan. Whole staff very pleasant and friendly!
They helped us get our new SUV. We worked with salesman Shawn Taylor and he was great. The whole team we worked with stayed after closing hours and got us taken care of in a time efficient manner. Would recommend working with Shawn 👍🏻
I was very happy with the deal. Then after we got home and looked over the paperwork. We noticed they charged us 1K more than agreed upon. What made us look at the paperwork was they had us come back after leaving to sign another paper. It was paper that gave the dealership the 1K rebate. So they knew what they were doing. We just happened to notice when we got home. I had to make another trip in to get it all corrected.
I drove 250miles from my home to get the crolla cross hybrid that I wanted that only Mcdaniels toyota had. The drive was worth it. Staff were so friendly and helpful expecially Matt. I would highly recommend purchasing a vehicle from them. The experience was great.
Wow! Great experience all the way around. We bought a suv today and they were fast, professional, and willing to deal. I highly recommend checking them out, I certainly will again.
We just bought a used 2017 Toyota Highlander from McDaniels Toyota and after searching for a reputable and honest dealer who had customer service aimed to accommodate the customer first, we found Colton Dickerson a sales person with McDaniels. Colton made our buying experience amazing between taking the time to really listen and understand what we were looking for and also being mindful of our budget all while being a very personable young man and very knowledgeable about the vehicles we were looking at.. if you want a Toyota and don’t want the pressure that most dealers put on customers. ... Read More 
Google - Feb 27, 2025
They were very friendly and efficient. Quite professional. It was a pleasant experience.
The entire team did a great job. I was in need of a vehicle and when I could not find the car I was looking for, they found it and brought it to me for consideration. It was perfect and they helped me close the deal. Very supportive on follow up and they let you know that they care about your business. They will definitely be my go to moving forward. Thank you all for your help.
Do NOT purchase an EV from this dealer. They are not registered with the IRS and you will NOT receive the tax credit that they specifically advertise on their website. They are lying if they say that you can just claim it on your taxes because they need to be registered with the IRS and submit the vehicle VIN through the portal for you to get the credit. They are deceitful and shady. As of right now, they are causing hundreds of new EV owners to loose out on $7,500 because they did not tell us the truth.
I will update ... Read More 
Google - Feb 25, 2025
Test drove 2016 blue Honda civic lx 2 weeks ago, came back and told them it needed rear brakes and rotors. I was told by multiple people that it went through a safety inspection but they would double check. Few days later car was sold. Today I noticed the car is sitting back where the trade ins sit and to no surprise it still needs rear brakes and rotors. That tells me everything i need to know about McDaniel's GM superstore.
It has been a few years since I have bought from mcdaniels gm but it seem that was the last time,the experience I had this evening has completely ruined the reputation of mcdaniels.first the amount of questions just to even test drive is beyond ridiculous.and the very insulting offer on a trade in was just plain disrespectful. But luckily the next gm dealer was able to make an awesome deal and a fair offer on trade chevrolet of bucyrus will continue to get my business from now on! They treat you with respect unlike mcdaniels and it ... Read More 
Google - Dec 31, 2024
This place is horrible overpriced and when I had my car done there they swapped my battery without my knowledge when my old battery had a warranty on it. Now they refuse to do anything about it. Will never go there again. Also have had other people tell me they like to steal out of your vehicle by swapping part with there own vehicles
Best price on a new Sienna Platinum literally in the entire country! Most dealers were selling at MSRP and many were adding a markup due to their popularity and scarcity. They had one priced basically at the MSRP of the next lowest trim (Limited). After talking to the sales person (Raislin) and being assured there was no back story I drove 100 miles to purchase the car still somewhat leery and ready to walk away if this was a "bait and switch". It wasn't and there was no attempt to upsell me other than the usual extended warranty ... Read More 
DealerRater - Nov 12, 2024
I have waited a couple of years to write this review. I am torn because i absolutely love my truck. Our first salesman was extremely nice , just new. We first leased my tacoma and have now bought it.. first I had dash cam installed and they sent it to columbus, It came back with extra miles on it than should have been. We didn't complain and we should have.
They did not and still do not take me serious when I complained there may be a issue with the truck. ( I took it off roading ) they still tell me ... Read More 
Google - Jul 24, 2024
Absolutely not worth buying from here. They will sell you a dirty truck or car and only take some money off if you clean it yourself. The vehicles you sell should be ready and cleaned when someone needs to leave with a vehicle that day. They will also lie and say they called your partners phone two times and left a vociemail saying your oil change is done. My partner never received phone calls or voicemails from them. He had to wait 2 hours. Ive had my oil change and it doesnt take no 2 hours. Its a joke here and ill ... Read More 
Google - Jul 19, 2024
Scheduled an oil change for 9am. At 9:30, I asked for my keys and left as the truck had not been pulled in yet. Evidently the service manager, Steve, knows how to take a reservation but isn’t very good at time management.
I had a mixed experience with this company. The staff I spoke to on the phone were very nice and receptive. However, I would not recommend attempting to buy a car out of state or over the phone. I was told the paperwork would be sent to me, and despite waiting all day for it so I could make a deposit, the car I was interested in was sold to another buyer.
$28,000 for a 2018 Chevy Suburban LT with 121,000 miles and many many many cosmetic damage. Plus I have a 2013 Chevy Suburban LTZ fully loaded with basically every option you can imagine all the way down to telescoping pedals with 103,000 any they only offer me $5000 trade in??? Are you kidding me? These people are seriously delusional! I would never go there ever! If you want to be taken advantage Of definitely go there but if you want reasonably priced vehicles in excellent condition please stay away and go to Delaware! Horrible place!
They may be good with oil change but diagnosis and fixing not so much. 14 Cadillac ATS going into low power mode and they charged almost $1100 to put on a valve cover gasket , still doing the same thing. It has a low oil pressure code , just googling I learned more than they told me about what could be causing the problem, it’s like they want us to keep bringing it back and making money than to just fix it
If I could I would've given 0 stars. Had car 4 days and it was in the shop due to shaking. Had rental for almost 2 weeks, i had the rental longer than actual car. Then when going back to get car still had to pay 900$, tork converter was bad. Mcdaniel did me dirty with selling me a lemon and I'm not satisfied at all with overall service by mcdaniel employees. Financial lady said you guys sold the red traverse knowing it had problems and you did the same exact thing to me! Yall are dirty. Will not be recommending you ... Read More 
Google - Apr 1, 2024
Best price on a Tundra in 3 states. Great customer service and financing through Toyota financial went smoothly.
I had the great pleasure of being haggled within an inch of my life and finally buying my 3rd car on February 8th, 2024 from McDaniels just for them to sell me a $20,000 SUV where the windshield wiper fluid isn’t coming out. You can give the car an oil change, inspect it when it comes in from whoever sold it to you, and “have it detailed” (shine it up so I don’t notice the scratches down the side) but can’t make sure the windshield wiper fluid sprayers are working properly ??? Now I have to find time out of ... Read More 
Google - Feb 12, 2024
I had a 10:00 a.m. appointment for an oil change and tire rotation. I also asked them to check the tire pressure sensor on one tire. My vehicle was not seen by a service tech until 11:30 a.m. What is the use of making an appointment if you have to wait so long to get service???
Had to wait almost 2 hours with an appointment just for an oil change. Service person did not give me full explanation of the total cost of replacing filters including labor until after I had to pay for it. If I had known upfront I would have declined replacing the engine and interior filters until later. Extremely disappointed. Will find someone else to service my car from now on. I’ve already told my family and friends about my bad experience and others in the waiting area were complaining about the wait times. I could only see one tech working on ... Read More 
Google - Dec 29, 2023
My wife had been looking for a 2023 Rav4 Limited with the Gray Metallic exterior. I was finally able to find one on the internet that was listed by McDaniel Toyota. I sent an E-Mail on a Monday night inquiring as to it's availability and was pleased to get a response from Internet Manager Kelsie Phillips early the next morning. She put me in touch with salesperson Sydnie Salisbury who worked with me over the next two days to to hash out a deal for the 2023 Rav4 Limited and my trade-in of a 2019 Rav4 Adventure. She also set me up ... Read More 
DealerRater - Dec 7, 2023
Having an horrific and horrible experience trying to get my car fixed at this place..My car has been there for a month and is still there.i have been requesting a courtesy car since the start but they never have a car returned to them so they can provide me one. This is so pathetic. The manager Brandon was apparently painting from 10am to 5pm. I called them 6 times asking to speak to him.Wish I had paid the extra towing and got it worked on in columbus.
Took my prius in because my new fob I ordered online wouldn’t work. Found out the fob needs to have the manufacturer chip in it to work. $257. for a new fob. I asked if programming it was included in the price and was told yes. I brought my car in to get it programmed, and they tried to charge me for it. The new fob will not unlock and lock my doors and I still have to use a key. They want to charge me to wipe the entire memory and reprogram it so that that will work. I ... Read More 
Google - Oct 20, 2023
This dealership is insane. Mounds of paperwork before even talk price. The way they do business is an insult to their customers. I was there almost an hour and still didn’t get a price. My advice go somewhere else.
While in active negotiations with a Salesman from the dealership over multiple days who’s last message to me was instructing me to make an offer, which I immediately did, the vehicle was sold out from under my nose without so much as a text message or phone call. While a business is a business, there has to be some expectation of professionalism and courtesy between dealership and customer. I am extremely disappointed in the overall establishment to say the least, buyer beware.
Someone damaged my 4runner in January. I got an estimate the next day at McDaniel's and was told they couldn't fix it until beginning of May. The last week of May came, and I had heard nothing. I contacted them on 5/24 and was told they would have their secretary contact me. It's 8/20 and no one has ever reached out to me. I also had a bad experience when I purchased my 4Runner. I would NOT recommend McDaniel's to anyone, and I will never go back there. I have to start over to get my car fixed ... Read More 
DealerRater - Aug 20, 2023
I contacted McDaniel Toyota via phone on a Saturday morning @ 9:30 inquiring about a 2016 Cadillac SRX they have advertised on "Auto trader" & left a message for a sales person to please contact me. Within 30 minutes I received a call back from "Sean" who took all my questions. Less than 15 minutes he was back on the phone with me and we worked out a deal in less than an hour from when I first called even though I am 180 miles from their dealership. By the end of the day he arranged to have the car delivered to ... Read More 
DealerRater - Aug 12, 2023
If you are from out of state, don't purchase here. They will not file the paperwork so you can get your car registered. I'm going on 2 months and still can't register this car. My neighbor bought a car in Ohio, and the dealership they used did their paperwork for out of state registration, so they got their car plated in 3 weeks. You are warned.
We were looking for a low mile used car, and boy do they have a nice selection! Couldn't ask for a nicer experience, very impressed with the helpful and professional sales people. The showroom and entire dealership is impressive. Family owned and it shows, everyone worked together . Thank you chris, we love our gently used car!
Called me on 6-16 to tell me my car was ready to be picked up. I get there and it will not start. Have had 3 different diagnoses and really upset/angry I wasted my time coming up there to not be able to pick my vehicle
Salesperson are great but I bought 3 new cars in 5 years. Our new highlander battery died 13 months after purchase. Dealer won't warranty battery bc we traded in with aaa and we should have called Toyota # for help instead. (While stuck at an intersection. All 3 cars are new and won't go here anymore. I don't know of any battery that has less than 2 years
Went to dealership today with high hopes of purchasing the exact truck I had been searching for. When I sat down with the salesman all he asked was how much I wanted my payment at and what I had to trade in. When I requested an out the door price and total amount of vehicle was he told me he could not give me those numbers unless I filled out a credit app. I the asked what the price would be if I paid cash he then states he can’t sell me truck unless I finance for at least 6 ... Read More 
Google - Apr 21, 2023
I am pleased to report that salesman Gabe Payne offered me great service on the sale of a 2023 Toyota Tacoma. Thanks Gabe!
They are really overpriced for generic parts. Should install Toyota parts for the money they charge. Had 9:30 appointment. At 10:30 they told me why they thought should be done. At 11:30 they were done. Too long.
Did not honor oil change coupon that was mailed out.
I had a 20.00 gift card that you sent me in the mail. I gave it to the service department and noticed the next day that it wasn't applied. I don't know what happened just figured I would try someplace else next time
Never called about parts for vehicle. Took almost two days just to do a diagnosis. I will be looking for somewhere else and wouldn’t recommend especially when it seems like they don’t want my business to begin with. Maybe if they wouldn’t overbook their service would be better
Hardly any new cars very shady business practices and over priced too. Go elsewhere!!!
Absolutely worst sales and management team. I drove 6 hours one way to find out the car I was picking up was having serious issues with the rear drive train. The noise coming from it was loud and they clearly didn't care as they acted like it was not a problem. If you are looking for a car don't buy here despite the paid reviews. I wasted 12+ hours of my life to view something that should not be for sale and the manager basically acted like it was a normal occurrence. No apology or any concern
With two emails I did not get a response. Not upset but surprised that no one replied.
I searched a 500 mile radius from Indianapolis for the best value in a late model F150. I found it at McDaniel Toyota.
As I was over 200 miles away, I relied on the observations and descriptions of my Sales Person, Joe Peters, to characterize the truck. He was so detailed and thorough I decided to reserve the truck sight unseen.
Upon seeing the truck. Joe was spot on. I immediately purchased it for the full asking price, which I thought was a bargain, and headed home with my truck in about an hour.
I am delighted with my purchase and my ... Read More 
DealerRater - Nov 4, 2022
I traveled 4 hours to get to this dealership. I did purchase a new SUV. I never did receive my title so I called the dealership about this issue. Their response was, Its my place to find the title not theirs's. I finally had to call Chevy, to ask for their assistance. Long story short its going to be 10 weeks before I can receive my title. If then. People was rude to me and my daughter. All I want is the title to my SUV.
Overall great experience. Very disappointed with Manager John Halko but Salesperson Joe Peters and Finance Manager Matt Moloney were terrific. In fact I'd rate Joe as one of the best I've ever dealt with.
Diagnosed with the wrong problem on my car
If I could give zero stars I would. I was told they would not sell me a brand new car at MSRP because I would not trade in my car. They told me "we are not making enough money off you" and that is word for word from the salesmans mouth. It just shows they could care less about the customer and only care about how much money they can make from you. I will never again think about buying a car from McDaniel Toyota and I will make sure others know to stay away as well. This &... Read More 
Google - Aug 22, 2022
If I could give zero stars I would. I was told they would not sell me a brand new car at MSRP because I would not trade in my car. They told me "we are not making enough money off you" and that is word for word from the salesmans mouth. It just shows they could care less about the customer and only care about how much money they can make from you. I will never again think about buying a car from McDaniel Toyota and I will make sure others know to stay away as well. This &... Read More 
DealerRater - Aug 21, 2022
I brought my 2016 Chevy Silverado 1500 Custom into the McDaniel's GM dealership to be serviced at 8:04 AM on Tuesday, May 17th, 2022. I requested an appointment the week prior to have an oil change, tire rotation and alignment on the service day. When I walked in the building to the service desk and after confirmation of my services, I was told by Kenny that it would be 3-4 hours total for the services to be completed. While I was shocked to hear that, I was still able to arrange me a ride back to my residence via my grandmother. At approximately 11:00 ... Read More 
Google - May 28, 2022